The bar is high, but not as high as you'd think when it comes to Hamilton's record-breaking residential sale prices. Of all recorded sales in Hamilton proper*, the highest (EVER) is $5.165M and the top ten starts at $2.475M. That's eye-opening when you think of many recent listings that are a hair close of this list or in bumping position. You have to stop and think, "Is THIS home that's for sale worthy of all-time status?!"

*Excludes the amalgamated areas of Dundas, Ancaster, Flamborough, Waterdown, Stoney Creek and Glanbrook

Tricia Taffs, realtor at RE/MAX Escarpment Realty Inc, has been selling real estate in Hamilton for 20+ years and she never ceases to be impressed by the range of properties our city has to offer. And she agrees that some of these sales make you do a double take (and maybe even say a quiet "really?")

Photo by Cathy Koop Photography

Have a look at Hamilton's top-10 most expensive homes below. Some are undeniable. Others are questionable. I personally do not get #2. Literally insane IMO.

Happy to report that the majority (6/10) are 75+ years or older. The oldest is 115 years.

Local realtor, Doug Folsetter, with Real Broker Ontario Ltd., says, "Hamilton is full of hidden and unexpected gems...with every style and era represented, the City is an architecture lover's dream."

When it comes to the allure of these 'bar raising' homes Folsetter indicates that buyers of properties like these are looking for uniqueness -- a show piece to call their own. Some want a home that sticks out for all to see, while others covet a private location to enjoy peaceful serenity.

Tricia Taffs loves most how many of these homes offer a true sense of place and personality. She expresses, "Real estate is emotional, and buyers at this level are often drawn to something that feels truly unique."

If you're asking me, it has to be one of a kind and have instant WOW factor. That's subjective, but if chocka-block with original character and craftsmanship + situated on a lush, mature lot, the deal is sealed. #6, #5, #4 and #1 deliver!

Now, without further ado, here's the much anticipated top-10 list!

HONOURABLE MENTION

79 Markland Street - SOLD for $2,450,000

Photo by VOGEL Creative Photography

Circa 1903. Closed in June 2022. Just under 1/3 acre lot. Over 4,000 square feet of living space. Property taxes during time of sale were $9,000. Estimated at $12,000+ now. Record breaking feature: Professionally designed and restored three-floor family house in coveted South Durand Heritage District + professionally deigned backyard oasis with inground saltwater pool.

Photo by VOGEL Creative Photography

#10 147 Mountain Park Avenue - SOLD for $2,475,000

Photo by VOGEL Creative Photography

Circa 2017. Closed in November 2024. 0.15 acre lot. Over 5,000 square feet of living space. Property taxes during time of sale were $16,000. Record breaking feature: Killer city views in your backyard with modern open concept design, featuring floor to ceiling windows.

Photo by Owner

Photo by VOGEL Creative Photography

#9 57 Seneca Avenue - SOLD for $2,480,000

Photo from OneHome

Circa 2016. Closed in January 2022. Just over a 1/3 acre lot. 3,360 square feet of living space. Property taxes during time of sale were $13,000. Currently estimated at $15,000. Record breaking feature: Nice home with a triple car garage and entertainer's yard with inground pool, but I personally don't get why this is a top 10.

Photo from OneHome

#8 70 Mayfair Crescent - SOLD for $2,600,000

Photo from OneHome

Circa 1952. Closed in November 2023. Nearly 3/4 of an acre lot. 8,000 square feet of living space. Property taxes during time of sale were $21,000. Record breaking feature: One of the best streets in the city across from McMaster University. Award winning professionally landscaped 327' deep backyard with inground pool. 88 Mayfair (#6) is far superior IMO, but I get the appeal of single level living to many buyers.

Photo from OneHome

#7 112 Chedoke Avenue - SOLD for $2,602,000

Photo by VOGEL Creative Photography

Circa 1915. Closed in June 2022. Nearly 1/3 of an acre lot. 3,200 square feet of living space at the time of the last sale (now cited as 3,966). Property taxes during time of sale were $11,000. Currently $15,000. Record breaking feature: Backing onto the Chedoke Golf Course this 333' deep property is an outdoor entertainer's paradise with heated salt water pool.

Photo by VOGEL Creative Photography

Currently back on the market and offered at $3,350,000, vying for the #2 spot (Good! Bump 166 Concession St)!

Photo from Facebook- Realtor Jen Ziegler - RE/MAX Solid Gold

#6 88 Mayfair Crescent - SOLD for $2,880,000

Photo by VOGEL Creative Photography

Circa 1938. Closed in February 2024. Almost 3/4 of an acre lot. Nearly 5,000 square feet of living space. Property taxes during time of sale were $19,000. Record breaking feature: One of the best streets in the city across from McMaster University. Parklike 372' deep ravine lot.

Photo by VOGEL Creative Photography

#5 9 Turner Avenue - SOLD for $2,900,000

Photo by Cathy Koop Photography

Circa 1910. Closed in February 2024. Almost 1/3 of an acre lot. Nearly 5,000 square feet of living space. Property taxes during time of sale were $18,000. Record breaking feature: Centre Hall, Durand South, locale. Say no more! But seriously, arched pocket doors, stunning improvements, timeless interior design, double wide lot and backyard oasis with inground pool.

Photo by Cathy Koop Photography

#4 125 Aberdeen Avenue - SOLD for $2,970,000

Photo by APi 360 Photography

Circa 1909. Closed in August 2024. Almost 1/4 of an acre lot. 8,000 square feet of living space. Property taxes during time of sale were $19,000. Record breaking feature: So much to love! Iconic street appeal and stunning original woodwork from paneling, to intricate inlays to built-ins and statement staircase.

Photo by APi 360 Photography

#3 407 Queen Street S - SOLD for $3,225,000

Photo by Ground2Air Media

Circa 1917. Sold in May 2025. Nearly 1/2 an acre lot. 7,494 square feet of living space. Property taxes during time of sale were $23,000. Record breaking feature: Indoor pool room and high-end luxury finishes throughout (chandeliers in bulk!). Prestigious South Durand Heritage District with high traffic 'show off' location. Definitely a bling home, but for similar amenities I would have much rather invested $3.3M in Dundas (try to secure 36 Cayley St) or something in Old Ancaster.

Photo by Ground2Air Media

Photo by Ground2Air Media
Photo by Ground2Air Media

Photo by Ground2Air Media

Photo by Ground2Air Media

Photo by Ground2Air Media

Photo by Ground2Air Media

Photo by Ground2Air Media

#2 166 Concession Street - SOLD for $3,250,000

Photo from OneHome

Circa 2021. Closed in September 2022. Almost 1/3 of an acre lot. 3,669 square feet of living space. Property taxes during time of sale were not listed as it was a new build, but estimated at around $15,000 today. Record breaking feature: I honestly can't think of one. Says city and lake views but doesn't hold a candle to #1.

Photo from OneHome

I don't get it! Especially shocking given the knockout at180 Concession couldn't sell for $1,899,999 (listing expired Aug 2024).

Photo by VOGEL Creative Photography

Shocking update: 166 Concession Stret sold in May 2025 for $1,850,000 ($1,450,000 less than the 2022 purchase price)!!!

#1 31 Colquhoun Crescent - SOLD for $5,165,000

Photo from OneHome

Circa 2007. Closed in November 2021. 1 acre lot. 13,000 square feet of living space with parking for 24 cars! Property taxes during time of sale were $36,000!! Estimated at $42,000 today!!! Record breaking feature: Breathtaking views of the city, escarpment and Lake Ontario.

Photo from OneHome

Although we just finished viewing (and drooling over) Hamilton's most expensive home sales of all-time, Tricia Taffs at RE/MAX reminds us how far your home-buying dollar can still stretch here compared to larger markets like Toronto - especially when you factor in architecture, lot size, and location. Her parting words (of wisdom), "Perhaps Hamilton is still one of the best-kept secrets in Ontario?"

Wednesday, July 23, 2025

THE $5.165M BAR

Photo from Facebook- Realtor Jen Ziegler - RE/MAX Solid Gold

Photo from Facebook- Realtor Jen Ziegler - RE/MAX Solid Gold

Photo from Facebook- Realtor Jen Ziegler - RE/MAX Solid Gold

Photo from Facebook- Realtor Jen Ziegler - RE/MAX Solid Gold

Photo from Facebook- Realtor Jen Ziegler - RE/MAX Solid Gold